View Thread

Navigating Peer Review Governance: Addressing Reviewer's Comments

  • 1.  Navigating Peer Review Governance: Addressing Reviewer's Comments

    Posted 07-09-2015 10:29
    Apologies for cross-posting


    There are still a few places left in this exciting PDW which offers a unique opportunity to work closely with editors to discuss both the reviewing process and actual reviews.

    It is designed to support early and mid-career researchers to turn a Revise and Resubmit (R&R) into a published article. The transformation of scholarly interest and research practice into a published article requires a process of navigating the peer review process which is inherently complex for the novice researcher. There are systems and protocols which need to be understood when the researcher receives feedback on articles submitted for publication. While the ‘pressure to publish’ dominates many academic careers, particularly among junior and mid-career researchers seeking to establish careers in an increasingly competitive academic marketplace, opinions about what constitutes ‘publishable research’ is increasingly divided. More than ever university governance systems emphasize the need for researchers to submit to top ranking journals early in their careers and predictably they receive reviews critical of their work. When they are invited to undertake a R&R, the researcher’s ownership of their writing process itself makes this reviewer feedback inherently difficult to assimilate; the words and the process expectations seem harsh and, often, incomprehensible. Negotiating the difficulties inherent in the review process and to prepare an appropriate response requires careful balancing of the feedback received and an understanding of the nature of the review process. In small groups of no more than eight persons, editors from a range of peer-reviewed journals aligned with the MED and CAR areas of interest will discuss specific examples of reviews and more general issues of peer review governance.

    This PDW is designed to support early and mid-career researchers to turn a Revise and Resubmit (R&R) into a published article. Pre-registration is required. To register online, please contact Dr. Blackman, the workshop organizer (d.blackman@adfa.edu.au) to obtain a code, then visit https://secure.aom.org/PDWReg. Deadline to register online: August 7.

    We are very pleased to announce the participation of the following scholars:

    Coordinator: Deborah A. Blackman; U. of New South Wales
    Participant: Andrew Harry Barton; Nottingham Trent U.
    Participant: Angela M Benson; U. of Brighton
    Participant: Jon Billsberry; Deakin U.
    Participant: Robert P. Gephart; U. of Alberta
    Participant: Richard T. Harrison; U. of Edinburgh
    Participant: Paul Hibbert; U. of St Andrews
    Participant: Stephen A Leybourne; Boston U.
    Participant: Allan Macpherson; U. of Wisconsin, La Crosse
    Participant: Janine O'Flynn; The U. of Melbourne
    Participant: Stephen T.T. Teo; Auckland U. of Technology

    Sponsored by the MED Division, this workshop is scheduled for Saturday, August 8, 2015 12:00PM - 1:30PM at the Vancouver Convention Centre in Room 207.

    Deborah Blackman
    Professor in Public Sector Management Strategy School of Business UNSW, Canberra

    Twitter: Debbiebl2
    View my research on my SSRN Author page:
    http://ssrn.com/author=525115


    a:PO Box 7916
    CANBERRA BC ACT 2610
    p: +61 (0) 2 62688831
    e: d.blackman@adfa.edu.au

    CRICOS Provider Code: 00100G

    This message in intended for the addressee named and may contain confidential information. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete it and notify the sender. Views expressed in this message are those of the individual sender and are not necessarily the views of the University College of the University of New South Wales.